Recovered anorexic warns against Johnson’s “unnecessary” calorie-counting scheme

*DISCLAIMER*: This website is produced by journalism students. The views expressed on the site are not that of Newcastle University. They are the personal views of the student editors and contributors to this website. Seek professional advice for any health related matter. Every effort is made to ensure that information contained on this website is accurate and up to date. However, information is subject to change and we can not accept liability for the accuracy of all the information presented at any given time. We do occasionally provide links from our website to information from third parties. We accept no responsibility for information obtained through such links.

Recovered anorexic and body positive blogger Emmanuelle Gammage said the Prime Minister’s proposed introduction of calories on menus could “create a complicated relationship with food rather than aiding our health.” The Better Health campaign forms part of a government scheme to tackle the obesity crisis in the UK.

The scheme will entail an advert ban on food high in fat, sugar or salt (HFSS), restrictions on “buy one get one free” (BOGOF) sales in supermarkets, calorie counting on food menus, a review of “traffic-light” labelling on packaging and an NHS expansion to weight management services. Johnson’s decision was influenced by his own experience with coronavirus and how experts are saying the obesity crisis “is the single most important modifiable risk factor” in the fight against it.

But the Prime Minister’s announcement has been criticised by campaigners and charities, who fear this kind of “fat-shaming” and “embarrassing” rhetoric could worsen eating disorders like anorexia, bulimia and binge-eating disorder.

21-year-old Emmanuelle Gammage is a recovered anorexic who promotes body positivity, happiness and self-care on her website, Discover Yourself Love. She now openly discusses recovery and encourages others to choose this too. In our episode of Tea Time with Holly, we unpack further how lockdown could be a trigger for many young women with eating disorders.

TEAser on @hollyspillingthetea: Emmanuelle Gammage

Commenting on Johnson’s announcement, Gammage said: “I just think it’s absolutely unnecessary. It shames people and it makes people feel guilty for eating. I would imagine that many people would choose a lower calorie option even if they didn’t want to because they felt like they should. But that’s not good for your mental health and it causes guilt and restriction around food – which is why so many people develop eating disorders.”

Emmanuelle Gammage
Tea Time with Holly Spotify podcast: Emmanuelle Gammage uncovers her personal struggles with body image and how lockdown may be a trigger for those with eating disorders. Make sure to have a listen!

Eating disorder charity BEAT also criticised the government’s proposed scheme, reminding the government of the changes that need to be made towards anti-obesity strategies. Their report outlines the ways in which these strategies can cause distress to people at risk of developing an eating disorder, including “policy makers to be mindful of the language used when discussing weight, shape, food or exercise, due to the potential for this to promote the thin ideal, body dissatisfaction and calorie restriction.

The Chief Executive, Andrew Radford, said: “We are concerned that the campaign will encourage people with eating disorders to use the promoted weight loss app, which fails to prevent under 18s or people with low-weight from using it, despite it not being suitable for them. It is also worrying to see a renewed emphasis on measures such as calorie labelling, as evidence clearly shows that these risk exacerbating eating disorders of all kinds.

Andrew Radford, Chief Executive of BEAT charity

Petitions like this, which are campaigning to stop calories being published on children’s menus, outline the problems for young people and body image. Rachel Jenkins started the petition with the comment: “If from an early age children view food in terms of numbers and feel as if certain foods are ‘demonised’, they may face eating disorders in further adulthood.

The government’s press release highlights how “obesity is one of the biggest health crises the country faces”, with 63% of adults in England being overweight. This is inline with newfound evidence, which suggests “living with excess weight puts people at greater risk of serious illness or death from COVID-19”.

Eating disorder charity BEAT highlight other common eating disorders: “A 2017 study by Hay et al found that anorexia accounted for 8% of cases, avoidant/restrictive food intake disorder (ARFID) 5%, binge eating disorder 22%, bulimia 19%, and other specified feeding or eating disorder (OSFED) 47%.”

Johnson’s decision also caused a stir on Twitter. One user commented on the personal impacts this would have on her recovery from an eating disorder. @evebennettx tweeted: “After multiple years of recovery from really really obsessive calorie counting I still struggle to eat in restaurants with calorie counts, I find it so so so difficult – it’ll be even worse for people still in the middle of their battle.”

Johnson’s Twitter storm: people take to their keyboards to show their disappointment at the PM’s announcement.
Johnson’s Twitter storm: people take to their keyboards to show their disappointment at the PM’s announcement.

Gammage was also concerned about the ramifications. She said: “calories literally only tell us how much energy is in something – when we see a big number it makes us anxious! What we should be focusing on is nutritional value rather than calories. A super healthy salad could be on there and it might be really high in calories, but it’s all goodness!”

Some Twitter users have been supportive of Johnson’s scheme. @hankancool tweeted: “Would be needed across the Western world, where we are eating ourselves to death and having to spend more money on health care treating disorders.”

Johnson’s announcement follows his “Eat Out to Help Out” scheme. The scheme, running between 3 August to 31 August, allows customers eating at certain restaurants a 50% discount on food or non-alcoholic drinks.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s